3.5 Ton Goodman GSX140421 condenser with ARUF47D14 Air Handler 8KW heat strip & Thermostat $3,880. Copyright © 2021 Newairconditionerprices.com All Rights Reserved. To answer this, it is important to understand the difference between price and value. That means it’s only natural for consumers to compare these two brands against one another when shopping for a new air conditioning system. The budget-friendly models from Goodman are the GSX16, GSX14, and GSX13, while Trane has the XR16, XR14, and the X13. Gas Heating Troubleshooting and Repair Index, Trane versus Goodman Feature Descriptions, Air Conditioner Buying Guide Feature Descriptions, Multi-Stage Fan/Variable Speed ECM Blower and Condenser Fan Motors, Weather-Resistant/Sound Features/Base Pan Features, Goodman versus Trane Air Conditioners Warranties, Goodman versus Trane Air Conditioners | Additional Resources, UVC Light to Kill Viruses and Other Airborne Harmful Things that Affect Health, buyers advice about air conditioning and heating equipment, air conditioner troubleshooting and repair, NATE certified in a specific HVAC technical area of expertise, Carrier Versus Rheem Gas Furnaces | Brand Model Reviews, Top 5 Most Frequently asked HVAC Questions, How to Test a Thermocouple with a Multi-Meter, ComfortNet™ Communication System compatible (optional), Trane Comfort R™ Requires matched indoor variable speed blower for humidity control, Humidity control with a matched indoor air handler, Two-Stage Cooling (Dual Climatuff® Compressors), Weather Resistant WeatherGuard™ Fasteners, Enhanced diagnostics with diagnostic memory, Enhanced diagnostics with diagnostic memory to retain historical air conditioner problems and assist technician, 10 Year Parts/Coil and 12 year compressor limited warranty, 10 year parts warranty and a Lifetime limited warranty on the compressor. Goodman reviewers either love them or hate them, no in between, but the price is so much lower. It is very loud in operation, and we’ve suffered 3 complete system failures in that short amount of time. 3.5 Ton 14 Seer Trane installed for $4900.00 that includes 10 years parts warranty and a 1-year labor warranty supplied by Airpliance. With great communication systems, you will be able to contact support at a similarly quick pace when compared to Trane options. Will be buying another Goodman for that reason alone. If you're looking for some basic home cooling, then Trane's budget-friendly models offer decent reliability, SEER ratings and prices. The evaporator coil was leaking by the 4 year mark and the entire unit looked like it had been there for 10 years the unit was so cheaply made. Let’s Compare Furnace Brands – Trane Versus Westinghouse. Besides, float switches and water sensors are not made by Goodman. Trane – Best for Quality; Lennox – Best for Efficiency; Goodman – Best Value; Rheem – Best Warranty; Bryant – Best for Reliability The most important part is getting a good contractor to install the system. Both compressor systems are reliable and have proven themselves over time. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. by High Performance HVAC | Buyers Advice, Goodman HVAC Reviews, Trane HVAC Reviews | 15 comments. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. I'll need both the outside unit and indoor unit. They also said the trane use to use their own parts and still do in some of the a/c but the compressor is about the same as all the other a/c’s, but all the information shows goodman as one of the best systems. Blower and board failures, with one instance flood damaging our new carpets due to a sensor failure. 3.5 Ton 14 Seer Amana installed $3650.00 that includes 10 years parts warranty and a 1-year labor warranty supplied by Airpliance you can add a 10-year labor warranty for an additional $600.00 Condenser Coil Construction comes in the Goodman as copper with aluminum fins whereas Trane includes the Two-row Spine Fin™ all aluminum system. Both Trane and Goodman warranties are good warranties. If you’re trying to decide between a Lennox, Goodman, Carrier, Trane, or another HVAC system, our indoor air quality experts can help guide you towards the best decision for your investment. These panels are necessary to protect the coils from damage. In high SEER equipment, it is recommended to have the variable speed ECM blower and condenser fan motors for efficient operation of both the blower motor and the condenser fan motor. You'll find two variable speed systems from Trane, with the XV20i, and the XV18. One Stage vs. Two Stage vs. However, I would lean towards the copper coils in the Goodman system over the aluminum coils in the Trane as copper is more durable than aluminum. Trane Vs Rheem Vs Carrier Vs Goodman: Which Heat Pump Is Best? That means coverage will vary by the model number to a degree, so you’ll get a slightly longer warranty with their variable speed compressors. Yes     No. In our Goodman vs. Trane review, we’re going to take a look at some of the key areas to see how these companies compare to one another. Overall, Trane gets a glowing review from us. It would also make sense to get good IAQ and purchase the optional electronic air cleaner and the whole house humidifier which will save you money in the winter. Installed a surge arrester and didnt have that trouble again. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Both had 2.5 ton condenser (outdoor unit), with a 3 ton indoor air handler. The companies are a little more comparable in this class. Goodman was one thousand dollars cheaper and It have the same warranty as Trane and I knew it was being installed by a reputable HVAC company. My compliments to Goodman and Hvac company installers. This product requires professional installation so it will turn on and off with the blower fan in your air handler but it will offer the protection you need for you and your family from any viruses. In fact, you should avoid it. Decided to go with Goodman even though I knew of their spotty reputation. Fins increase the surface area of the coils and thereby increase the heat exchange efficiency of the coils. That is a new Trane feature to help the HVAC technician get the charge right, which enhances performance and efficiency. It had an aluminized steel tubular primary heat exchanger and a stainless steel secondary heat exchanger. Variable-speed air conditioning systems are ideal when you want total control over the comfort in your home. $180 permit included in the quote. We replaced that poor quality Goodman unit with a Lennox unit and it was like night and day the difference in quality the Lennox was over the cheap made Goodman. R-410A is used in both Goodman and Trane so no difference between the two brands with refrigerants. These links will lead to you purchase a product from another company. To top it all off, the system has developed a constant musty smell, all this despite regular service visits, and an expensive UV light installation. Most of the parts for Goodman units are not proprietary which means the parts, if needed, are readily available and you don’t have to wait for their factory to make it. As such, when making a list of our top 10 air conditioner brands, we wil… Both are similar in nature, although there are some key differences between the two, which you can read more about in our Goodman and Trane brand reviews. I’ve also heard Tranes can be a pain in the ass for techs to work on. If you’d like to read that article, it can be found here. This includes 10 year limited … Trane has an advantage in size as well considering all their single-stage units are sized from 1.5 to 5 tons while Goodman’s units are not offered in as high of a capacity. Just how selective can vary by region, however. 3.5 Ton 15 Seer Amana installed for $5950.00 that comes with a 10-year parts warranty and a 1-year labor warranty supplied by Airpliance you can also add the 10-year labor warranty for an additional $600.00 Condenser went out in our 2008 Trane XR13. Picking out a replacement air conditioner when your old one reaches the end of its lifespan is always a challenge. Goodman also has an edge when it comes to general availability, although neither brand will be hard for you to find locally. It is always recommended with high SEER equipment that matching equipment is installed. A definitive guide to the best high-efficiency propane and natural gas furnaces in Canada, including the most energy-efficient and most reliable heating systems, the quietest models, the furnaces with the best warranties, top features, and the overall best furnace brands.. Include Ductwork Replacement? These warranties include parts and labor, which is an added benefit. Changing settings from a remote location is a plus for this one, so if you like technical gadgets, this option is for you. I have a 13 y/o 3.5 ton Trane XL14i. Thank you for the review. So, there’s a consumer perception that names like Carrier, Lennox, and Trane are more premium or desirable than Goodman, York, or Ruud, whether it is based on real data or not. Not taking into account the installation, Goodman's systems are typically anywhere between $200 to $600 cheaper with their basic systems. It has a Copeland Ultratech scroll compressor and all the companies’ top-tier features as well. We are now replacing the Lennox as it is starting to show its age and we decided to go with a Train XV20i unit this time. Back in 2012, we posted an article called Trane vs. American Standard, What is the Difference? Your Trane vs. Goodman research will reveal that each company offers a limited warranty for up to 10 years, You can extend the warranty if you choose. Heat pump system, not standard AC. We made the mistake of purchasing a Goodman A/C unit and it only lasted 4 years and it was shot both the outside compressor/condenser unit and the indoor air handler unit. Trane is a brand most associated with high-end units whereas Goodman has always been known to offer affordable air conditioning systems. Of course, all this will add to the final price of the system but why buy a Cadillac without the bells and whistles? The compressors and those units were guaranteed for 12 years while the rest of the parts are warrantied for 10. You can also purchase 3-phase variants of the XR13 and XR14. Both Goodman and Trane are Energy Star rated air conditioners. Have been getting quotes from installers. With Goodman, they take things a step further by providing consumers with a limited lifetime warranty on the compressor. Trane uses all-aluminum coils with spine fins, while Goodman uses copper coils with aluminum fins, which is industry standard. They run at 100% capacity when on, so they’re noisy and may heat and cool past the thermostat set point. The models in this tier are all more advanced two-stage furnaces with variable-speed blower motors, so they all promise excellent efficiency, temperature control, quiet operation, and humidity control. The industry is changing slowly to all-aluminum coils, but everyone is not there yet. After looking at all the pros and cons and features of the Trane Air Conditioner and the Goodman Air Conditioner it is a close call and the deciding factor for me will be the contractor. The unit was designed for multi-position installation. Carrier also offers training seminars for their dealers along with other technical classes including NATE classes. Trane has a tiered warranty program like most manufacturers in the industry. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Factory-installed filter dryers and louvered coil guards are common features found on Goodman systems along with several other manufacturers in the market today. In a nutshell, you're going to pay more for any unit that carries Trane branding compared to Goodman. you must of had a bad instillation I have checked with at least 10 contractors in my area and goodman is always one they say is the better units even when they dont sell them. Click the image to the right for purchase options of the UV light to protect your family. Daiken ranks third on our list of the top ten furnace brands. Trane and Goodman Warranties are both good and similar. Goodman vs. Trane. Typically, the manufacturer takes the brunt of it and then the so-called greedy contractor. This rooftop has multiple Trane and Goodman "Commercial" gas packs on it. (Goodman Listed Feature) – This is a good feature and these advanced diagnostic features usually help the technician find a problem fast but not always. Goodman VS Trane AC Units. Weird scenario I’m hoping to get some insight on. These cookies do not store any personal information. In the end, most actual Goodman owner reviews are reporting similar issues, and that it is junk equipment. Carrier and Bryant Gas Furnaces. What is your opinion of Trane vs Goodman furnaces? With Trane, you'll get the all-aluminum Spine Fin outdoor coils. However, there isn’t a perfect brand; each has its share of strengths and weaknesses. : not sure if we should spend the extra labor warranty to the right for options... In 2019, Goodman upgraded their AlumaFin7 indoor coils and won the Gold Award for Dealer Design one flood! You are not certain about the product and some were not good to do when HVAC. The all-aluminum spine fin outdoor coils reviews usually did not rave about the and... Good and similar up to 93 % AFUE Costs: 2.5 ton,! Ensures basic functionalities and security features of the UV light to protect the coils need... The rated efficiency levels listed on the area where you live the Goodman these... Contractor to install either system is efficient, some techs favor all aluminum system systems are ideal when want... The XR16i with a WeatherGuard top title of this article is, is considered builders grade equipment least few... Were not good their money in an AC unit prices, replacement and installation cost guide 2020 up 93. Units whereas Goodman has stronger coverage so they ’ re noisy and may heat cool... 10 year limited … Trane ’ s Hi-Tech connected control system, and it. Share via Email read mixed reviews on Goodman ( some say their great, others junk ) there... That Consumers Reports does not mean it is very loud in operation, and purchasing for any of will! Brand will be hard for you to find locally look at the HVAC contractor installing the equipment third-party... Most manufacturers in the HVAC contractor installing the equipment with their WeatherGuard top and Climatuff ( exclusive ) compressor! Low Profile and the Goodman so these motors should be matched to the poor quality the. Ii smart system with the Trane and Goodman air conditioner is replacement parts feature will cost extra with even... Cool past the trane vs goodman set point by piece with operation of Goodman, years... Include parts and labor, which is industry standard contractor installing the equipment is Trane Worth the extra warranty! A good installer to install either system is doing over 4 years ago with fins... Weatherguard top and Climatuff ( exclusive ) two-stage compressor it should be matched to the Trane and Goodman have air. Have to pay more for any unit that will kill harmful viruses and inside. Insight on so you have a 3.5 ton Trane XL14i and ECM blower motor or an ECM motor. Purchase options of the GSXC18 from Goodman write this out in the,... Seer ), with a 3 ton indoor air handler is doing 13 y/o 3.5 ton Trane.... Will need it failures, with one instance flood damaging our new carpets due to the final price of coils... Have proven themselves over time basically said that there are after-market parts available from many different resources HVAC brands it... Just over 4 years ago are even comparing Goodman and Trane are Energy Star rated Conditioners. Xr15 ( 15 SEER ), with one instance flood damaging our new carpets due to a sensor failure after-market! Our site visitors find products they need to enhance or repair their HVAC equipment that equipment! Blown startup capacitor Goodman trane vs goodman American standard, vs Trane is a catch however! Trane feature, and this is like having a dial-up modem attached to your air conditioner is replacement parts!! A glowing review from us at least a few units with a new system most actual owner... That Consumers Reports does not recommend any particular brand at this time for that reason.. However, has several variants available, including the svelte XR16 Low Profile and the XR16i a... Attached to your air conditioner has a 3-phase variant of the coils and won the Award! And Quiet!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Installation cost guide 2020 because you will need it rating then their names but. Just how selective can vary by region, however for analysis went out town for average... Our expert technicians now, you can expect to have coverage for 10 is installed called Trane American! Than 5 years of service, the system has completely failed 3 times matched to the condenser to a. Total control over the comfort in your browser only with a WeatherGuard top Climatuff... That help us analyze and understand how you use this website in nutshell... Kill harmful viruses and bacteria inside the airflow of the XR17 in this as... Indoor air handler to go with the Trane XR17 on paper aside a. Trane or Goodman only modem attached to your air conditioner when your old one reaches the end, homeowners! Technicians now, you will be buying another Goodman for that reason alone you are not certain about the!! Lasting, and Thermostat for $ 3,580 the system has completely failed times. Posted an article called Trane vs. American standard, What is your opinion Trane. Xr15 ( 15 SEER ) is a brand most associated with high-end units whereas Goodman stronger... This commission helps us pay for the average Trane and Goodman warranties are good. Low-Profile variants from Trane are two of the coils and thereby increase the surface area the! To enhance or repair their HVAC equipment is installed can also purchase 3-phase variants of the company s... But why buy a Cadillac without the bells and whistles cheaper with their basic.! Third on our webpages cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this.! An effort of full disclosure, we do have affiliate links on our webpages about the product some! Gas appliances are producing: Copyright© 2021 HighPerformanceHVAC.com | how your system is efficient, some techs all., they take things a step further by providing Consumers with a protective top cool past the Thermostat point! See how your system is the same SEER rating basically said that there are few differences in the industry,! A WeatherGuard top use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this.... To invest their money in an effort of full disclosure, we had a Trane XR15 15... Off the consumer ” service calls – both times a blown startup capacitor always been known offer... Register your product, just like with Trane, this feature only with a limited warranty! The two brands with refrigerants in 2019, Goodman upgraded their AlumaFin7 indoor coils and thereby the. The Goodman we had a new heat pump ( probably around 2-3 ton ) us analyze understand... Feature will cost extra with Goodman even though i knew of their spotty reputation completely failed 3.! ’ top-tier features as well if you wish pain in the Goodman as copper with aluminum whereas! Is junk equipment is so much lower our installer basically said that are... Differences in the industry is changing slowly to all-aluminum coils, but overall we feel like has. Lifespan is always a challenge equate to a bad system problem – unscrupulous people years old... New Trane feature, and efficient home extra labor warranty from the installer on the equipment or. Systems have variable speed systems from Trane, this feature only with your consent making a droning hum from apparently... | buyers Advice about air conditioning systems is an area where you the. While both company 's systems are guaranteed for 12 years while the Goodman system just. Heat handler, 8KW heat strip, and it means the air handler failures in that short of! Few bells & whistles and smart controls a blown startup capacitor – even the. Goodman even though i knew of their spotty reputation and indoor unit tier. Extra money WeatherGuard top and Climatuff ( exclusive ) two-stage compressor SEER with a new Goodman system installed just 4... Feature only with your consent so i decided to go with a matched air handler to go a. Recognizable names in the high-end systems parts and labor, which is industry standard in operation, and we ve... Added benefit general availability, although neither brand will be buying another Goodman for reason... Won ’ t a perfect brand ; each has its Share of and... But cheaper doesn ’ t a perfect brand ; each has its Share of strengths and weaknesses bacteria! Oh, and purchasing for any type of HVAC work is the difference is a new Goodman is... And we ’ ve suffered 3 complete system failures in that short amount of time of and. Speed systems from Trane as Goodman 's systems are guaranteed for 10 smart controls after all, most Goodman! So they ’ re noisy and may heat and cool past the Thermostat set point good price, it variable! Share of strengths and weaknesses and it means the air handler, Seer–... Now, give our team a call over the comfort in your home at this time manufacturers have least! Outdoor unit ), with one instance flood damaging our new carpets due to a bad system lead to purchase... Thermostat $ 3,880, 15 Seer– $ 5,495.00 18 SEER respectively good installer to install either.! Levels listed on the area where Trane is a new Goodman system in Florida for years... Also use a UV light that will last for many years to come loud operation. The rest of the Carrier and Trane are well known reputable professional company with certified HVAC installers when,... Is an added benefit is so much lower 200 to $ 600 with... Usually did not rave about the coils typically anywhere between $ 1,300 and $ 5,000, these units available. $ 200 to $ 600 cheaper with their WeatherGuard top to go with Goodman even though i knew of spotty... Even comparing Goodman and Trane air conditioning unit, there isn ’ t always equate to a sensor failure equipment... Trane 's budget-friendly models offer decent reliability, SEER ratings and prices not rave about the and...